homemade shamrock shake with whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, and a cherry on top

Homemade Shamrock Shake Dupe with Honey

Craving a Shamrock Shake? This guide will show you how to make it easily at home with simple ingredients. Plus, we make it even sweeter with raw honey! Learn the quick steps, key ingredients, and fun customization ideas. Let’s dive into making your own minty shake.

This shake would taste delicious with a Feta Turkey Burger

A Delicious Honey Shake

  • The Shamrock Shake has been a popular St. Patrick’s Day treat since 1967 and supports charitable efforts, like Ronald McDonald House.
  • For a homemade Shamrock Shake, use vanilla ice cream, whole milk, mint extract, and green food coloring, with options to customize flavors.
  • Serve your Shamrock Shake with toppings like whipped cream and chocolate syrup, and store leftovers properly to enjoy later.

What is a Shamrock Shake?

The Shamrock Shake has a rich history that dates back to 1967 when it was first created by a McDonald’s owner in Connecticut to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day. This minty milkshake quickly gained popularity and became widely available in select U.S. locations by 1970. Over the years, shamrock shakes have cemented their place as a beloved seasonal treat, especially during the lead-up to St. Patrick’s Day.

Notably, this shake has also played a role in charitable efforts. In 1974, the profits from its sales contributed to the establishment of the first Ronald McDonald House, a testament to its impact beyond just being a delicious dessert. The shake saw a national debut in 2012 after years of being a regional specialty, and its 50th anniversary in 2020 brought it back nationwide alongside the introduction of the OREO Shamrock McFlurry.

The allure of the Shamrock Shake lies in its creamy vanilla base with a distinct mint flavor that is both refreshing and indulgent. Available annually from late February through March, this shamrock shake season delight has people lining up to get their hands on it. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a newcomer, the charm of the Shamrock Shake is undeniable.

Looking for St. Patrick's Day Recipes? Try this Honey Glazed Corned Beef!

Key Ingredients for a Homemade Shamrock Shake

For a copycat Shamrock Shake, gather vanilla ice cream and whole milk. These ingredients provide the creamy, dreamy texture. Add mint extract cautiously, as it’s quite potent.

Feel free to experiment with flavors by using chocolate or mint chip ice cream for a richer taste. Non-dairy milk options like almond milk or coconut milk can also substitute whole milk, catering to various dietary needs.

Add green food coloring (liquid food coloring works better than gel food coloring) for the iconic emerald hue and a touch of raw honey for sweetness. With these ingredients, you’re set to make a your own Shamrock Shake.

What Kind of Vanilla Ice Cream?

When crafting your homemade Shamrock Shake, the choice between vanilla bean ice cream and regular vanilla ice cream can significantly impact the flavor and texture of your minty creation. Vanilla bean ice cream, known for its rich and creamy texture, is speckled with real vanilla bean flecks, offering a more intense and authentic vanilla flavor. This depth of flavor enhances the overall taste of your Shamrock Shake, making it a luxurious treat.

On the other hand, regular vanilla ice cream provides a more subtle vanilla taste, which allows the mint extract and green food coloring to shine without being overshadowed. This option is perfect if you prefer a lighter vanilla presence in your shake.

Both choices are delicious, and the decision ultimately depends on your flavor preference. Whether you opt for the boldness of vanilla bean or the simplicity of regular vanilla, your Shamrock Shake will be a delightful indulgence.

Our Sweet Clover Honey would be perfect for this recipe

How to Make a Shamrock Shake

Allow the ice cream to soften for about 15 minutes before starting; this helps achieve a smoother blend and perfect consistency.

Combine the softened ice cream, whole milk, mint extract, raw honey, and green food coloring in a food processor or blender to combine ice cream. Blend until smooth, which takes about a minute. A food processor works well for a lighter, fluffier shake.

Although it’s tempting to prepare ahead, make your Shamrock Shake fresh for the best texture. Thawing a pre-made shake can alter its consistency.

Garnish your serving glass with chocolate syrup before blending the shake. This enhances visual appeal and adds extra flavor.

Blend until completely smooth and serve immediately to enjoy the best texture and flavor. Follow these steps for an easy homemade Shamrock Shake!

Customizing Your Shamrock Shake

Customize your Shamrock Shake by adding chocolate syrup, crushed Oreo cookies, or chocolate shavings. For a stronger mint flavor, add fresh mint leaves or extra mint extract.

Mint Oreos can enhance the flavor and add creaminess. Avoid overmixing to maintain the vibrant green color. Pour chocolate syrup into the serving glass to preserve the shake’s hue.

Add a splash of crème de menthe or other flavored liqueurs for a boozy twist, creating an elevated version of the classic treat.

Incorporate the cookie portions of mint Oreos for a mint chocolate cookies & cream shake, adding crunch and extra minty flavor. Customization possibilities are endless.

Serving and Garnishing Ideas

Topping your Shamrock Shake with whipped cream and a maraschino cherry gives it a classic look. Freezing serving glasses helps maintain thickness longer.

Drizzle chocolate syrup inside the glass for elegance. Sprinkle crushed cookies, chocolate candy, or green sugar decorating sugar on top for added crunch and visual appeal.

Create a milkshake bar for gatherings with toppings like whipped cream, maraschino cherries, and chocolate syrup, allowing guests to customize their shakes with a copycat recipe.

Serve in malt glasses for a nostalgic, diner-style presentation. These serving and garnishing ideas ensure your Shamrock Shake is both delicious and picture-perfect.

Ever wonder about the origins of the Leprechaun?

Storing and Freezing Your Shamrock Shake

Freeze leftover Shamrock Shake in a freezer-safe container, leaving space at the top for expansion. Seal tightly and label with the date to avoid freezer burn and maintain taste.

For short-term storage, keep your milkshake in the refrigerator for up to 24-48 hours in an airtight container to preserve freshness.

Gently stir or blend the stored shake to restore its original consistency before enjoying. These tips ensure you can enjoy your Shamrock Shake even days later.

Nutritional Information

This homemade Shamrock Shake has around 343 calories. It’s an indulgent yet delightful way to celebrate the season.

Enjoy it in moderation to savor its minty, creamy goodness without the guilt.

Keep your skin hydrated with our plant-based Sea + Tea Body Cream

More Minty Milkshake Recipes

If you love minty milkshakes, try various year-round variations. Blend vanilla ice cream, whole milk, and peppermint extract until smooth for a refreshing treat.

Enhance your minty milkshake with crushed Oreos or chocolate syrup. These additions elevate flavor and add texture, making your milkshake more enjoyable.

Whether it’s a Shamrock Shake or another minty creation, these recipes are sure to delight your taste

Try this Honey Shamrock Shake

Making a homemade Shamrock Shake is both easy and rewarding. With the right ingredients and a few simple steps, you can recreate this beloved seasonal treat in the comfort of your own kitchen. Customize it to your liking, serve it with flair, and enjoy the minty, creamy goodness that has made the Shamrock Shake a favorite for decades. Happy blending!

star

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use non-dairy milk to make a Shamrock Shake?

Absolutely, you can use almond or coconut milk to whip up a Shamrock Shake! It's a tasty way to keep it dairy-free.

How long can I store a Shamrock Shake in the freezer?

You can store a Shamrock Shake in a freezer-safe container for several weeks, just remember to leave some space for it to expand. Enjoy it whenever you're in the mood!

What can I add to my Shamrock Shake to make it more flavorful?

To amp up your Shamrock Shake, try adding chocolate syrup, crushed Oreos, or even some fresh mint leaves. These extras will totally take your shake to the next level!

How can I keep my Shamrock Shake green when adding mix-ins?

To keep your Shamrock Shake green, just pour any chocolate syrup on top instead of mixing it in. This way, you can enjoy your mix-ins without losing that signature green look!

What is the calorie count of a homemade Shamrock Shake?

A homemade Shamrock Shake has around 312 calories, so it's a tasty treat you can enjoy without too much guilt!


Kara holding a hive frame in doorway of cabin

About the Author

Kara waxes about the bees, creates and tests recipes with her friend Joyce, and does her best to share what she’s learning about the bees, honey, ingredients we use and more. Read more about Kara