Every December the same question comes up: which cookies are we making this year. Here is our answer. Eight holiday cookie recipes made with honey, six more sweets for the tray, and everything we have learned about baking, storing, and swapping them.
Family recipes come first. But there is always room on the list for one more.
Why Bake Christmas Cookies with Honey
Honey does three things in cookie dough that granulated sugar does not.
- It holds moisture. Honey attracts and keeps water, so cookies stay soft and chewy for days. That matters when you bake on Sunday for a party on Friday.
- It browns. The sugars in honey caramelize quickly, which gives cookies a deep golden color and a slightly crisp edge.
- It tastes like something. Sugar is sweet. Honey is sweet and floral, or buttery, or dark and malty, depending on the jar. It stands up to ginger, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

Tupelo Honey has a delicate, buttery flavor that suits holiday baking.
Eight Holiday Cookie Recipes Made with Honey
Honey Ginger Cookies
Remember ginger snaps? These are the soft, chewy version. Honey Ginger Cookies land between sweet and spicy, and the recipe uses no milk, eggs, or butter.
Gingerbread Cookies
This tradition started with a batch of anatomically correct gingerbread men made to amuse friends. It stuck. Our Gingerbread Cookies are for rolling, cutting, and decorating, so set aside an afternoon and put the kids to work.
Chocolate Dipped Honey Peanut Butter Cookies
Honey Peanut Butter Cookies are good plain. Dipped in dark chocolate and finished with crushed nuts, they are the first to disappear.

Honey and Potato Chip Chocolate Chip Cookies
The unexpected ingredient is potato chips. Potato Chip Chocolate Chip Cookies are chewy, crunchy, salty, and sweet in the same bite.
Dairy-Free Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies
Baking for someone who skips dairy? These dairy-free oatmeal chocolate chip cookies give up the butter and keep the flavor.
Oatmeal Cookies with Dried Fruit
Oats, honey, and a mix of dried fruit. These oatmeal cookies with dried fruit are chewy and not too sweet. Good with coffee at three in the afternoon.
Honey Chai Tea Cookies
Think snickerdoodles, with chai spice where the cinnamon sugar would be. Honey Chai Tea Cookies are soft and smell like the inside of a tea tin.
Holiday Fruitcake Cookies
Fruitcake has a reputation. Fruitcake Cookies fix it: candied and dried fruit, toasted nuts, and a splash of bourbon in a cookie sweetened only with honey.

Other Sweet Holiday Treats to Try
Cookies not your thing? A cookie tray has room for more than cookies.
Cranberry Orange Biscotti
Not the easiest recipe here, and worth the effort. These Cranberry Orange Biscotti use no eggs, milk, or butter, and they do not come out hard and dry like the ones in the coffee shop jar.
Pistachio Granola Chocolate Bark
Granola pressed into a slab, covered in dark chocolate, scattered with chopped pistachios. Break Pistachio Granola Bark into pieces and pack it in tins.
No-Bake Oatmeal Peanut Butter Honey Balls
No-bake recipes save oven space when you are baking in volume. Oatmeal Peanut Butter Honey Balls take a few pantry ingredients and one bowl. We keep more ideas like this in our list of snacks with honey.
Honey Chocolate Truffles
Heavy cream, butter, chocolate, honey. Honey Chocolate Truffles are simpler than they look, and they make a good gift.
Tupelo Honey Fudge
Nothing says “I love you” like fresh refrigerator fudge. This dark chocolate no-bake fudge needs no oven and sets in the refrigerator.
Coconut Macaroons
These coconut macaroons are sweetened with a little Basswood honey, and they round out the tray.

Our limited edition Cranberry Honey brings a tart, festive note to any of these recipes.
Ways to Make a Cookie Recipe Your Own
- Change one flavor. A little peppermint extract in chocolate chip dough. Orange zest in gingerbread.
- Add crunch. Chopped nuts, shredded coconut, or crushed graham crackers.
- Mix your chocolates. Dark, milk, and white chips in the same batch.
- Try another flour. Swapping in some whole wheat or rye flour adds a nutty flavor. Almond flour does too, and it behaves differently, so start with a small swap.
- Add a splash. Rum or bourbon, for the grown-up tin.
- Roll in color. Colored sugar or sprinkles before baking.
Still short on ideas? Our National Cookie Month post has more cookies, and the honey nut recipes collection will stock the pantry.

How to Store Christmas Cookies
- Cool them completely. Warm cookies make condensation in a closed container, and condensation makes soggy cookies.
- Use airtight containers. Put parchment or wax paper between layers so nothing sticks.
- Keep kinds apart. Peppermint and ginger will flavor everything stored with them.
- Skip the refrigerator. It dries cookies out. Room temperature is fine for about a week.
- Freeze for longer. Use airtight containers or freezer bags, and thaw at room temperature before serving.

For the days the oven is off: our Haute Cocoa Luxe Soy Candle smells like dark chocolate.
Time-Saving Tips for Holiday Cookie Baking
- If the dough needs chilling, mix it before bed and refrigerate it overnight. You wake up with half the work done.
- For butter cookies, take the butter out of the refrigerator and put it in the mixing bowl about four hours ahead. Soft butter creams faster.
- Set up the kitchen like a production line. The night before, get out the tools and measure the dry ingredients into covered containers.
How a Cookie Exchange Works
Each guest bakes one kind of cookie and brings a batch to trade. You bake one recipe and go home with an assortment. It works well with neighbors or coworkers, and it is the most efficient holiday party there is.
After a day of baking for other people, do something for yourself. Our at-home spa day guide is built around the Experience Love gift.
What to Drink with Holiday Cookies
- Mexican Hot Chocolate, spiced and made from scratch.
- Dairy-Free Hot Cocoa, if spice is not your thing or you skip milk.
- Dairy-Free Eggnog, which is very good with gingerbread.
- An Old-Fashioned Hot Toddy, for late nights after the kids are in bed.
Start Baking
Pick one recipe you know and one you have never tried. Preheat the oven, find the good spatula, and call someone into the kitchen to help. Happy holiday baking from our Honey House to yours.


